Since I've accumulated so many Everlane reviews, I thought it's about time I sat down and organized them into the best (or at least my favorites), the honorable mentions, the mediocre (the "meh") and the not so great items I've purchased. I'll keep updating this post periodically as I get more and more Everlane reviews up on the site so keep checking back!
(In no particular order)
Everlane Modern Point Review: still looks great and is getting even more comfortable with each wear
Street Sandals: My favorite Everlane shoe so far
The Honorable Mentions
Cotton tees (of all styles): I'm personally a big fan of these casual and affordable shirts, but if you're looking for a really high quality tee then Cuyana or Grana are actually a bit better. The Everlane tees tend to have wrinkled and creased collars over time and if you get one snag, it will become a pretty big hole fairly quick. Also some colors (like the dark gray and the micro striped tees) which are made in Vietnam (the others are made in LA) tend to shrink. But like I said I'm a big fan because they look ok and I use them for work (and get grease stains or holes in my shirt all the time, so I don't feel as if I wasted a ton of money on these when I have to add them to my rags collection).
Everlane silk sleeveless top: I like the quality of their silk (though I think Cuyana's is better, but with everlane you get a better value).
Petra Tote: I originally loved this tote, but this tote doesn't age well. It stiffens over time and starts to feel rubbery (I think for a really great simple leather tote, Cuyana's Leather Tote might be better).
Pima Cotton Stretch tee: I originally liked this top but found that I never wore it because it was so fitted. I prefer Everlane's other cotton tees over this one.
Linen Crew Neck Sweater: I originally liked the sweater, but I never wear it because I don't think the style is as flattering as I first thought. I like the linen tees from Everlane much better.
Not So Great
(But this is according to my body shape and personal taste so take it with a grain of salt)